Comparison between Screw Chiller and Centrifugal Chiller

15 Jan,2025


Comparison of Screw Chiller Units and Centrifugal Chiller Units

Chiller units have a wide range of applications in industries and commerce, among which screw chiller units and centrifugal chiller units are two common types. They each have their own characteristics in terms of structure, working principle, and applications. Below is a comparison of these two types of chiller units:

I. Structural Characteristics

1. Screw Chiller Unit: Mainly composed of a screw compressor, condenser, evaporator, and expansion valve. Its structure is compact, occupies a small area, and is relatively easy to maintain.

2. Centrifugal Chiller Unit: Mainly composed of a centrifugal compressor, motor, condenser, evaporator, and expansion valve. Its structure is complex, occupies a larger area, but has relatively low maintenance costs.

II. Working Principle

1. Screw Chiller Unit: Uses a screw compressor to compress the refrigerant, dissipates heat through the condenser, absorbs heat through the evaporator, and finally throttles and reduces the pressure of the refrigerant through the expansion valve to achieve cooling.

2. Centrifugal Chiller Unit: Increases the pressure of the refrigerant through a centrifugal compressor, dissipates heat through the condenser, absorbs heat through the evaporator, and ultimately achieves cooling.

III. Performance Comparison

1. Screw Chiller Unit: Has a high cooling efficiency, suitable for medium and small cooling demands. It operates stably, produces low noise, and is suitable for places with high noise requirements.

2. Centrifugal Chiller Unit: Suitable for large cooling systems, has a large cooling capacity, and is suitable for places that require continuous and stable operation. Its operating efficiency is relatively high, but the noise is also relatively large.

IV. Application Comparison

1. Screw Chiller Unit: Widely used in medium and small air conditioning systems, industrial cooling, and other fields.

2. Centrifugal Chiller Unit: Suitable for large air conditioning systems, chemical, pharmaceutical, and other industries' cooling needs.

In summary, screw chiller units and centrifugal chiller units each have their advantages. Screw chiller units are suitable for medium and small cooling demands, characterized by compact structure and stable operation; while centrifugal chiller units are suitable for large cooling systems, with large cooling capacity and high operating efficiency. When choosing, it is necessary to consider the actual needs comprehensively.